Frosted Cinnamon Roll

$25.00
$21.00

Think Sunday morning cinnamon rolls without the added fat or extra calories. You can add water to use as a spread, filling or topping. 

Try it in your oatmeal or yogurt for a fun, delicious high protein snack. There are infinite ways to bake with Protein Cookie Butter.

Think cookies, waffles, pancakes, protein bars and so much more in a matter of minutes.

Frosted Cinnamon Roll
Frosted Cinnamon Roll
Frosted Cinnamon Roll

"It's like crack guys, I'm addicted. I'm prepping for a bikini competition right now so good tasting/healthy food is hard to come by. But dear god, I mix this in with some greek yogurt and it tastes like brownie batter. I'll also mix it into overnight oats and use it to top rice cakes/kodiak cake waffles. I did try baking with it once, but then that used up the whole jar and I was sad. (Even though the protein donuts came out tasting amazing) I'd recommend baking with normal protein powder and using this for delicious toppings."

Emily, Verified Purchase

"I've been following Zach (@theflexibledietinglifestyle) and these beauties (@proteincookiebutter) on the gram for a few months now. OK. First, Zach has changed my life and am forever grateful to have found him. I ordered the chocolate cookie butter and have been obsessed. I have a rather large sweet tooth, and this stuff smells and tastes like Oreos. TBH, I have been eating it as a powder mainly, but its good mixed with anything. Will be trying to recreate Zach's protein donuts with the cookie butter powder to make cookies n cream protein donuts. The macros on this cookie butter is unreal, and did I mention it tastes like a dream come true?!"

STEPHANIE, VERIFIED PURCHASE

"I have now officially tried all the flavors and can say they are ALL absolutely incredible! I literally do not go a day without using one of these! They are extremely versatile and I love using them for so many different things. I have been ordering regularly since January and can say these cookie butters have definitely been worth the price! I recommend everyone tries EVERY flavor. Extremely excited to continue watching this brand grow and hope to see more products in the future!! Keep up the amazing work!"

BROOKE, VERIFIED PURCHASE

product feature

POWER UP YOUR BREAKFAST

Stir directly into your oatmeal or yogurt to create a thick, delicious, protein-packed breakfast.

product feature

USE AS A SPREAD

Mix with water or milk to create an unreal spread to enjoy over toast or rice cakes .

product feature

MAKE UNREAL SMOOTHIES

Add to your morning or post-workout smoothies to enhance the flavor and add some extra protein.

endless recipe possibilities

With our versatile Protein Cookie Butter Powder, there is no shortage of recipes you can make. You're only limited by your imagination! We have a ton of free recipes for you to check out, with many more to come soon!

Protein Peanut Butter

Macros per 2 Tbsp (32g): 60 Cals, 2g Carbs, 3.5g Fat, 5.5g Protein!

Chocolate chip cookies

Macros for each Cookie: 74 Cals, 6g Carbs, 2g Fat, 7g Protein

oreo protein cheesecake

Macros per slice: 128 Cals, 11g Carbs, 4.5g Fat, 11.5g Protein

cinnamon sugar pretzels

Macros for each Pretzel Stick: 57 Cals, 7g Carbs, 1g Fat, 5g Protein 

brownie batter oatmeal

Macros for WHOLE Bowl with toppings:
647 Cals, 75g Carbs, 23g Fat, 40g Protein!

Banana nut muffins

Macros for each Muffin: 234 Cals, 23g Carbs, 6g Fat, 22g Protein!

View the recipe on Instagram

get more recipes

We're working on bringing you TONS of free recipes, but in the meantime, you can download the free Protein Cookie Butter Recipe Book to a bunch of simple recipes using our original trio of flavors.

get the recipes

find your FLAVOR

Oatmeal Cream Pie
Oatmeal Cream Pie
Oatmeal Cream Pie

Oatmeal Cream Pie

All the texture

Meet our newest seasonal flavor, Oatmeal Cream Pie. Little Deb has nothing on our spin of the beloved oatmeal cookie sandwich.  

Oatmeal Cream Pie mimics soft, sweet, chewy and delicious, spiced oatmeal cakes with a fluffy and creamy vanilla center. We think this makes the perfect pairing in your oatmeal, yogurt, or spread on rice cakes, English Muffins and more.


$21.00
Apple Pie
Apple Pie
Apple Pie

Apple Pie

THE NEW APPLE OF YOUR EYE. 

There are two types of people in this world: the "hold" or "pass the apple pie." This flavor has been perfectly crafted with balanced proportions of fresh apples, warm spices, and a signature buttery, flaky crust so that you'll never be able to"pass" on it again.

With this seasonal Cookie Butter at your disposal, granny had better step aside. There's a new baker in town. 

$21.00
Pumpkin Pie
Pumpkin Pie
Pumpkin Pie

Pumpkin Pie

LET'S BE BASIC, TOGETHER.

Fall is upon us with a quintessential season dessert.

Welcome, Pumpkin Pie Cookie Butter: sweet and spicy with undertones of cloves, cinnamon, nutmeg and ginger baked in a perfect golden crust. The vanilla-spiced cake texture plus unique spice blend takes our signature fall Cookie Butter to the next level.

Stock up, settle in and get cozy for the fall with the perfect baked pie you don't have to toil over to enjoy. 

$21.00
Cookies & Cream
Cookies & Cream
Cookies & Cream

Cookies & Cream

A classic and an essential 

Protein Cookie Butter started with Cookies & Cream and it's since become a customer favorite. Cookies & Cream is our nod to one of America's favorite cookies. But we add our own spin of deep chocolate flavor and a subtle touch to mimic the cream inside cookies.

If chocolate is your thing, this flavor is about to become a pantry staple. 



$21.00
Birthday Cake Batter
Birthday Cake Batter
Birthday Cake Batter

Birthday Cake Batter

WE'RE GONNA PARTY LIKE IT'S YOUR BIRTHDAY! 

There's a reason to celebrate this dairy free Birthday Cake Batter Cookie Butter. Imagine dipping your spoon into a THICCC funfetti batter- a harmonious combination of rainbow-flecked vanilla cake batter with sprinkles throughout. 

You can double dip, we won't judge. We think it tastes like childhood.

Disclaimer: may not preserve your youth but will taste dang good. 

*Contains Gluten 

$21.00
Vegan Brownie Batter
Vegan Brownie Batter
Vegan Brownie Batter

Vegan Brownie Batter

Get your spoon ready

Gooey, delicious, smooth brownie batter. Nothing but the best here. Our dairy-free Brownie Batter Cookie Butter replicates that thick batter that nobody can resist dipping their spoon into before it goes into the oven. 

So go ahead, dip and double dip away. We won't judge you if you end up eating this chocolatey batter straight off your utensils .

$21.00